Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Betting Tips - Major League Soccer 2026 Matchday 16

Columbus Crew's recent form

Columbus Crew's recent form shows a blend of results. They have secured wins against Atlanta United and LA Galaxy, alongside a notable 4-1 victory over One Knoxville SC in the US Open Cup. However, they have also experienced defeats, including a 3-2 loss to Red Bull New York and a 2-3 reverse against Minnesota United. Their most recent result before the break was a 1-1 draw with Burnley in a friendly match.

New York City FC's attacking threat

New York City FC possess an attacking threat in Nicolas Fernandez, who has been in impressive form, scoring 5 goals in his last 10 appearances. This attacking prowess was evident in their recent 3-0 MLS victory over Columbus Crew. However, their recent results have been inconsistent, with a 2-1 loss to Nashville SC and a 1-1 draw against Red Bull New York. They also suffered a 0-2 defeat to DC United. Despite these fluctuations, their ability to score goals, particularly through Fernandez, remains a key factor.

Team news and expected lineups

Both sides are expected to field strong starting lineups. Columbus Crew's predicted XI includes forwards Daniel Gazdag and Wessam Abou Ali, supported by midfielders Andre Gomes and Taha Habroune. Defensively, they are expected to rely on the experience of Rudy Camacho and Steven Moreira. New York City FC's expected lineup features forwards Arnau Farnos and Nicolas Fernandez, with midfielders Andres Perea and Kai Trewin providing support. The defence is likely to be marshalled by Thiago Martins and Tayvon Gray.

Tactical considerations

With both teams expected to field attacking formations, the match could be an open affair. Columbus Crew's "point to prove" motivation might see them start with high intensity. New York City FC, despite reported "significant number of absences" in attacking and creative areas, will likely look to leverage the form of Nicolas Fernandez. The defensive solidity of both teams will be crucial in determining the outcome of this MLS fixture.